Available for a limited time, Pizza Hut has introduced a new item, the Hershey’s Toasted S’mores Cookie. This item features Pizza Hut’s Ultimate Hershey’s Chocolate Chip Cookie, but this version is topped with toasted mini marshmallows, chunks of a Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bars and graham cracker pieces. This item is similar to something I reviewed about a month ago, the Papa Murphy’s S’mores Dessert Pizza so I’ll be able to feature a direct comparison of the two desserts. Pizza Hut’s Hershey’s Toasted S’mores Cookie is available for just $6.99.
I saw this item on commercials shortly after I had the Papa Murphy’s version. I was actually rather disappointed in the Papa Murphy’s version because of the texture, especially from the rolled oats that was on it. Since this version featured chocolate cookie as the crust, I was already going into this one with high hopes in comparison to what I had tried last time around.
In short, Pizza Hut’s version blew Papa Murphy’s version completely out of the water! This item tasted so much like the familiar campfire treat and in my opinion actually better because of the addition of the chocolate chip cookie. The cookie was soft and gooey but still was hard enough that it held up it’s consistency. Because of that, you were still able to eat this item with your hands without making a complete mess. I have never had the Ultimate Hershey’s Chocolate Chip Cookie on its own, but I would absolutely give it a go because just the cookie part of this treat was awesome! When you add the addition of the melted toasted marshmallow and graham cracker pieces, this dessert was heavenly!
I will say that if you get this item, cut it immediately into your servings. We had leftovers (which warmed up awesome with about 15-20 seconds in the microwave by the way), but the marshmallow was kinda hard to cut through after it congealed back together. It was easier to cut through when everything was still warm and fresh from Pizza Hut so I would recommend carving in and preparing your servings right away.
I was so impressed that I couldn’t believe it! This is one of the best dessert items I’ve ever had and I think you will think the same!